Our Top Ten Family Christmas Movies! We present these movies to you in no particular order. Choosing a favorite Christmas movie is like picking your favorite child. Ok, not really, but it’s not easy. Here are some of our favorites. What have we missed?
This screwball comedy perfectly stands up all the right dominoes and just gently tips over the first one. The owner of an important New York magazine invites himself and a returning war hero over to his author’s farm house in rural Connecticut to celebrate Christmas. Only trouble is, she’s not a farmer, lives in New York City, isn’t married, doesn’t have a baby, and she can’t cook. All of which her boss expects of her. A little cheesy, but mostly just great fun.
You can’t go wrong with Ingrid Bergman and Bing Crosby. A priest and a nun have differing approaches to the running of a school. Nominated for lots of Academy Awards, but largely forgotten.
So much better than any other version I’ve ever come across. This telling is engaging, reasonably true to the Dickens, includes some fun song and dance stuff, and ages well. Young kids will enjoy the introduction to the idea of “real literature” and the rest of us also like it. Sure, read the book and read it often, but I think Charles would be writing for the screen if he was alive now. (Scrooge, also a musical, and the George C. Scott version get runners-up awards.)
Weak on plot, strong on songs and dances. This was the first movie usage of the song “White Christmas” and it includes many other great Irving Berlin numbers. Bing Crosby sings and Fred Astaire dances as they fight over the love of a woman and a Hollywood agent. It begins and ends with Christmas.
Watch as Bing Crosby, Danny Kaye, Rosemary Clooney, and Vera Ellen put on a Broadway show in a Vermont ski lodge. With no snow. The magic of musicals and Christmas combine and all is well (and all are engaged) in the end. Great supporting cast as well.
I almost feel like this movie needs no introduction. This classic movie tells the story of George Bailey, a small town success who has always dreamed of bigger things. When things truly get bleak, he is given a glimpse. A glimpse of what his life, the town, and the people around him would be like without him. It helps that Jimmy Stewart and Donna Reed are just about the most watchable people on the planet.
Cary Grant made a Christmas movie?!? Most people don’t know this. He’s not exactly human in this film. With Loretta Young and David Niven.
By Rankin/Bass, these claymation classics deserve not to be forgotten. They seem to be falling by the wayside in the last few years in favor of animated movies. The stories are fun and the stylized stop-motion is well done and pretty to watch. And it’s got a cast of good voices and songs that were new.
Perhaps my favorite reading of Luke ever. This short little movie deserves a place in your heart and in your annual repertoire.
Bob Hope is a con man just one jump ahead of both gangsters and the police (and an old girlfriend). Then he dresses up like Santa to score some “charitable” donations… Written by Damon Runyon, who should already be on your list of favorite American short story authors. Watch the first half hour here.
This movie interestingly pits the sophistication of commerce and law against the straightforwardness of belief. The ending is less clear-cut than expected. Just like real life. It’s cheesy as all get out, but also full of believable, lovable characters and pretty good dialog. There is also a book version by Valentine Davies (the screenwriter) that is worth tracking down.
Ok, ok, you’re right. That was eleven movies. We wanted to include even more. Here’s the titles we left off the list:
How many have you seen? Are there any movies we’ve forgotten? What’s your favorite Christmas movie? Leave us a comment below.